Best practices & tips

Practical tips and best practices for designing a loyalty program that drives the right behaviours, balances value, prevents fraud, and keeps customers coming back.

Designing a loyalty program isn’t just about offering rewards—it’s about creating a compelling, sustainable experience that drives the right customer behaviours and delivers measurable business value. Below are some best practices to help guide your design process.

---

Start with clear objectives

Identify what success looks like for your program. Are you aiming to increase repeat purchases? Grow customer lifetime value? Encourage acquisition through referrals? Your goals will shape the rest of the design.

Know your customers

Understand how your customers currently interact with your brand and what behaviours you want to encourage. A good program nudges behaviour in a meaningful direction.

Keep the MVP simple

Start with a clear, focused core proposition—like earning points for spend—and build from there. Too much complexity at launch can confuse users and delay implementation.

Ensure mutual value

Great programs strike a balance between being exciting for users and commercially viable for the business. Choose incentives that align with your margins and objectives.

Mix up the reward types

Consider combining different types of rewards:

• Instant (e.g. points awarded after a purchase)

• Delayed (e.g. monthly member perks)

• Aspirational (e.g. high-value tier rewards or limited drops)

Make it dopaminergic

Consider layering in psychologically rewarding features to keep engagement high. Daily check-ins, surprise-and-delight mechanics, and prize draws or instant win rewards can all create dopamine loops that encourage repeat interaction.

Just note: in some jurisdictions, prize draws or instant win games may be considered lotteries if users have to exchange value (such as points) to enter. To stay compliant, you may need to offer a “no purchase necessary” or free entry route. Consult local laws before implementing—it’s the client’s responsibility to ensure their program complies with relevant legal requirements.

Introduce tiers or segments with intent

Only add tiers or segmentation when they serve a purpose—like unlocking better benefits for your best customers or targeting offers to low-frequency shoppers.

Think data-first

Plan your event types and payloads with your future rewarding and reporting needs in mind. You can’t act on what you don’t track.

Build in flexibility

Design your program logic in a way that allows for easy adjustment. For example, plan your integration and structure your rules so you can easily increase earn rates or run bonus point campaigns without needing dev work.

Monitor and mitigate fraud

Loyalty programs can be a target for misuse. Define clear program rules, implement technical safeguards, and regularly monitor for suspicious activity.

See

White Label Loyalty provides tools to help with fraud prevention (like Points earn, spend & balance caps) but is not responsible for detecting or managing fraud in your program. It’s your responsibility to monitor for misuse and act accordingly.

Manage points liability

Every unredeemed point represents a potential future cost, so it’s important to actively manage points liability. Make sure you:

• Regularly monitor your points issued vs. points redeemed.

• Set a clear expiry policy to prevent indefinite liability build-up.

• Define whether points are treated as deferred revenue or marketing cost in your accounting.

• Cap earn or burn activity if needed to stay within budget.

WLL provides tools to help track and report on liability, but it’s your responsibility to manage how your loyalty points impact financial planning and program sustainability. Talk to your finance team early when designing your earn and burn model.